Skip to main content

Understanding bank hybrids and their role in the capital structure

By Marsha Desouza

April 2025

AT1 hybrids gained popularity after the Global Financial Crisis (GFC) as a cost-effective substitute for equity. They typically pay investors a fixed yield and sit above shares in the capital hierarchy. Hybrids offer banks a cheaper alternative to raising equity. Traditional equity issuance requires higher returns (~9-10% p.a.), while hybrids cost around 7% p.a., making them a more attractive option.

For over 25 years, hybrids have been an integral part of global bank funding, providing a stable capital base while allowing banks to avoid excessive dilution of ordinary shareholders. However, post-GFC, regulators introduced new hybrid structures to simplify capital structures and mitigate risk.

The Australian hybrid market, valued at ~$40 billion, has been a successful funding source for banks and offers investors a higher yield than traditional bonds. Australian bank hybrids typically yield 3% above cash rates, compensating investors for potential conversion risks. ASIC and APRA have emphasised transparency in explaining these risks to retail investors. However, the main risk for investors is that hybrids are designed as a stress buffer for banks, and they have the potential to convert into equity during a bank’s financial stress*.

The collapse of Credit Suisse’s AT1 hybrids in 2023 demonstrated the risks associated with these instruments. Instead of converting to equity, Swiss regulators wrote down ~$17 billion worth of AT1s while allowing some equity holders to retain value—violating the capital hierarchy principles of Basel III. This incident led regulators, including APRA, to reassess hybrid structures and investor protections, ultimately deciding to phase them out from 2027.

The future beyond bank hybrids:

  • Regulatory Impact: APRA may push for simpler structures, reducing reliance on AT1 hybrids.
  • Potential Replacements: Banks may shift towards subordinated bond issuance instead of hybrids.
  • Foreign Hybrid Offerings: Overseas banks could enter the Australian market, offering retail investors new opportunities.
  • Superannuation Influence: The large pool of superannuation funds searching for yield could continue to support demand for hybrids.

If you currently hold bank hybrids and are looking to reinvest before maturity, contact us to discuss alternative investment options.

*Conversion risk: Convertible subordinated notes will be mandatorily converted into ordinary shares or written-off where APRA determines that (1) such conversion or write-off is necessary because, without it, the Underlying Bond Issuer would become non-viable or (2) without a public sector injection of capital or equivalent support, the Underlying Bond Issuer would become non-viable. An investor may receive ordinary shares worth significantly less than the principal amount of their Subordinated Notes and those ordinary shares may be subject to transfer restrictions.

To join our mailing list and receive these updates via email, please complete the following form: